Why asking questions works better than defending your fee
A seller holding a lower-fee offer is rarely only shopping on price. Most are saying "I am afraid of overpaying for something I do not understand." If you defend your fee, you confirm that fear.
If you ask where they are going and why, the conversation moves from a percentage to their plan, which is where you can help them most.
What the seller is really asking when they mention a lower-fee offer
When you hear "another company will do it for less," it usually falls into one of three groups. Group it first, then ask the binary question.
- Money group. They need to protect their dollars. Moving costs, a down payment on the next home, a tight budget.
- Trust group. They do not yet see what the extra fee buys. Nobody explained it.
- Comparison group. They have not talked to anyone else yet and want something to hold up against the offer they have.
The three binary questions to ask a seller with a lower-fee offer
Ask one at a time. Pause. Write the answer where they can see it.
The question that separates saving money from netting more
You
Quick question so I point you the right way: is the goal to keep the fee as low as possible, or to walk away with the most in your pocket at closing? Those can be different numbers.
The question that separates price from plan
You
When you picture the sale going well, is it mostly about the lowest fee, or mostly about being in [their where] by [their when]?
The question that earns permission to compare
You
Would it help if I showed you what I would do for you next to what they are offering, so you can see the two plans side by side? You can tell me which one fits.
What to say when the seller brings up the lower fee
When the seller asks you to match a 1% or flat-fee offer
Seller
They will do it for 1% (or a flat fee). Will you match it?
You
I hear you, and I would want to know that too. Can I ask first: what would you want them to do that you are not sure they will? [Pause. Write it down.] Let me show you what I would do for each of those, and then you can decide if the difference is worth it.
When a friend sold with a discounted agent
Seller
A friend told me a discounted agent sold their house just fine.
You
That is great, and it can work for some sellers. Can I ask: did they get the price they wanted, in the time they wanted? [Pause.] That is exactly what I would want to help you do, so let us look at your where and your when.
When the seller asks why they should pay you more
Seller
Why should I pay you more?
You
Fair question. Is it okay if I answer it with a question? [Pause for yes.] If I could help you net the same or more after the sale, would the fee still be the deciding part?
Do not say a lower-fee agent will do a worse job, and do not guess what they offer. Ask, and let the seller's answers show the difference.
The line that earns the right to ask for the listing
Use this after the seller names what they are protecting: their where, their when, and their top three must-haves.
You
If I meet those things for you, have I earned the right to ask for your business?
Then stop talking. Whatever they say next tells you where you stand.
The follow-up when the seller says "we want to think about it"
Within 24 hours, send one message in their own words.
Message
[First name], you said [their why] and that [their when] matters most. I put together the side-by-side we talked about. Would it be okay if I walked you through it for ten minutes this week?
You earned the permission to follow up when you asked the third binary question, so use it.
What to track after listing appointments with a lower-fee offer
Of the listing appointments where the seller mentions a lower-fee option, count how many times you asked all three binary questions and how many of those sellers signed. Review it once a week.
How to practice it this week
- Before the appointment, write the three binary questions on your notes.
- In the appointment, ask, pause, and write their answers where they can see you.
- Compare instead of defending. Put the two plans side by side.
- Ask the earn-the-right line.
- Follow up within 24 hours using their words.