Why binary questions work on seller objections
Twenty-five binary questions for the three objections you actually hear on a listing call. Every objection lands in one of three groups: Timing (they want to wait), Agent (not sure about the agent), or Avoidance (they want the call to end). Once you know the group, you stop arguing and ask one binary question that gets to the real reason behind the objection.
A yes/no question ends the call as soon as the seller says no, while a binary question keeps it going by offering two real options. If neither is true, the seller answers with the truth (Path C). The goal is to make it easy for the seller to tell you the truth.
How to use the binary question method on a listing call
- Listen for the group: Timing, Agent, or Avoidance. You only need to be right about which one.
- Ask the binary question exactly as written. Wait for a clear answer.
- Listen for the path: A, B, or C (a third answer that matches neither).
- Use the matching follow-up and keep the conversation moving without arguing.
Path C, the loop: if they give a third answer, don't argue. Reset, listen for the group again, ask the binary question that matches, and loop the playbook.
Timing objections: what to say when a seller wants to wait
The hesitation is conditional on time, market, or readiness. They are saying "not yet" instead of "no." Listen for: waiting, the market, interest rates, seasons, repairs, or current activity at the home.
1. "We're no longer selling / we're not ready."
You
Is that because you need more time in the home, or because it's not a good time to sell?
If they need more time: Got it, you're just pausing for now. When the home does sell, where are you planning to move to?
If it's not a good time: Got it, I hear that a lot. Would it surprise you to know that over [X] homes sold in our market last month?
2. "We are going to rent out our home."
You
Is renting more of a long-term investment plan, or a short-term move until the timing feels better to sell?
If long-term investment: Awesome, building a portfolio is a great strategy. What kind of return are you hoping to get by holding onto the property?
If short-term move: Makes sense, sometimes you just need a bridge. What market changes are you waiting for before you decide to sell?
3. "We are going to wait." (no reason given)
You
Got it. Are you waiting because of what's going on in the market, or because of your personal timing right now?
If it's the market: I hear that a lot. Is it the current interest rates, or the price you can get for your home right now?
If personal timing: Makes total sense, life happens and timing is everything. What does your ideal timeline look like moving forward?
4. "We'll wait until the market gets better."
You
Would a better market for you mean getting more for your home, or improving your next purchase?
If getting more for the home: Everyone wants to maximize their equity. What price point would make it worth it to sell right now?
If improving the next purchase: Buying power is a huge piece of the puzzle. When you do sell, where are you planning to move to?
5. "We'll wait until after the holidays / spring."
You
Is that because you have to wait, or would you move sooner if you found the right buyer?
If they have to wait: Got it. Are you waiting because of what's going on in the market, or because of your personal timing right now?
If they'd move sooner: Awesome, good to keep your options open. What would that ideal offer need to look like for that to make sense?
6. "Nothing is selling / rates are too high." (expired listing)
You
Is that feeling based on what you're seeing locally, or is that what your previous agent told you?
If seeing it locally: Important to keep a pulse on the neighborhood. What specific trends are you seeing that make you feel that way?
If previous agent told them: You have to trust the professionals you hire. How did they explain the lack of activity on your specific home?
7. "Nothing is selling / rates are too high." (not an expired listing)
You
Is that feeling based on what you're seeing locally, or more of what's in the news lately?
If seeing it locally: The local market is the only one that matters. What are you noticing about the homes that are actually selling around you?
If it's the news: The headlines can be intimidating. Would it surprise you to know that over [X] homes sold in our market last month?
8. "We need to do some repairs before we relist."
You
Do you feel like there are things that have to be fixed to get it sold, or just things you'd like to improve?
If have to be fixed: You want to put your best foot forward. What are the major repairs you feel are holding the house back?
If just improvements: A few updates can make a difference. What specific updates were you thinking about tackling first?
9. "We're getting a lot of action on the house." (FSBO)
You
Has that turned into any serious offers, or mostly just showings right now?
If serious offers: Sounds like real momentum. What's keeping you from moving forward with the offers you've received?
If just showings: Foot traffic is a good start. What kind of feedback are you getting from the buyers walking through?
Agent objections: what to say when a seller is not sure about the agent
The hesitation is about WHO does the work: your value, another agent's loyalty, or no agent at all. Listen for: another agent, family, a previous experience, commission, what an agent actually does, or doing it themselves.
10. "We're listing with our previous agent."
You
Are you going back to them because you were genuinely happy with the result last time, or more out of convenience?
If genuinely happy: Glad you had a great experience. What did you like best about what your agent did?
If convenience: Sometimes knowing someone makes it easy. If you had to go with a different agent, what would you want them to do differently?
11. "What will you do differently than my last agent?"
You
Was the issue that your last agent didn't have a clear plan, or that they didn't follow through on it?
If no clear plan: Very few agents have a proven plan. If you started fresh, what would you expect from the next agent you choose?
If no follow-through: That's frustrating, promises they didn't keep. Where do you feel they dropped the ball the most?
12. "You're the Xth agent to call / I'm getting a lot of calls."
You
Are any of them actually giving you something useful, or does it feel like everyone's just trying to get the listing?
If something useful: Value in different perspectives. What's the most valuable thing someone has shared with you so far?
If feels like a pitch: Probably feels like a broken record. What's the one question you wish an agent would actually answer for you?
13. "We're going to sell it on our own." (FSBO)
You
Are you going FSBO because you've done it before, or simply because you want to keep more money in your pocket?
If done it before: That experience gives you a leg up. What was your biggest takeaway from the last time you sold on your own?
If keep more money: Saving on fees is a huge motivator. How are you planning to attract the buyers willing to pay top dollar?
14. "What's your commission?"
You
Are you asking because you want the lowest rate, or because you want to make sure whatever you pay is actually worth it?
If lowest rate: Every dollar counts when you're selling. What's the most important thing to you besides the fee?
If worth it: You should expect a return on that investment. What results would make you feel an agent truly earned their fee?
15. "What do you do to sell homes?"
You
Are you more interested in how we get the home in front of the most buyers, or how we position it so it actually sells once they see it?
If in front of buyers: Exposure is the name of the game. What marketing do you feel was missing last time around?
If positioning to sell: Getting them in the door is half the battle. What feedback did you get on the home's presentation when it was listed before?
16. "Bring me a buyer / do you have a buyer?"
You
Is your goal just to find any buyer, or to put yourself in a position to get the strongest possible offer?
If any buyer: Sometimes speed and simplicity matter most. What's the main reason you're looking for a quick, quiet sale?
If strongest offer: You don't want to leave money on the table. What strategies are you using now to create that kind of demand?
17. "You agents all do the same thing."
You
Do you feel that way because the results have all been about the same, or because no one's really shown you anything different?
If results the same: I'd feel the same in your shoes. What specific results were you expecting that you haven't seen yet?
If nothing different shown: Lots of noise, little substance out there. What would a truly different approach look like to you?
18. "We want to try on our own a couple more weeks."
You
Is that timeline based on actual activity you're seeing, or just giving it more time before making a change?
If actual activity: Momentum is a good sign. What feedback are you getting from the buyers coming through?
If more time: Sometimes you need to see it through. What exactly needs to happen in the next couple weeks for you to feel successful?
19. "We already chose another agent."
You
Are you officially under contract with them, or just planning to move forward?
If under contract: Got it, best of luck to you. (Ethics: don't solicit where a contract is already in place.)
If just planning: Feels good to have someone you're confident in. What stood out from their marketing plan that you think will be key?
20. "We're listing with a friend / family member."
You
Are you working with them because they're truly the best option to get your home sold, or is it more about supporting the relationship?
If best option: What stood out from their marketing plan that you think will be key in getting your home sold?
If the relationship: Because it's that important, I have to ask: how will you handle the conversation if their effort isn't getting the results you need?
Agent objections: what to say when a seller is not sure about the agent
The hesitation is about WHO does the work: your value, another agent's loyalty, or no agent at all. Listen for: another agent, family, a previous experience, commission, what an agent actually does, or doing it themselves.
10. "We're listing with our previous agent."
You
Are you going back to them because you were genuinely happy with the result last time, or more out of convenience?
If genuinely happy: Glad you had a great experience. What did you like best about what your agent did?
If convenience: Sometimes knowing someone makes it easy. If you had to go with a different agent, what would you want them to do differently?
11. "What will you do differently than my last agent?"
You
Was the issue that your last agent didn't have a clear plan, or that they didn't follow through on it?
If no clear plan: Very few agents have a proven plan. If you started fresh, what would you expect from the next agent you choose?
If no follow-through: That's frustrating, promises they didn't keep. Where do you feel they dropped the ball the most?
12. "You're the Xth agent to call / I'm getting a lot of calls."
You
Are any of them actually giving you something useful, or does it feel like everyone's just trying to get the listing?
If something useful: Value in different perspectives. What's the most valuable thing someone has shared with you so far?
If feels like a pitch: Probably feels like a broken record. What's the one question you wish an agent would actually answer for you?
13. "We're going to sell it on our own." (FSBO)
You
Are you going FSBO because you've done it before, or simply because you want to keep more money in your pocket?
If done it before: That experience gives you a leg up. What was your biggest takeaway from the last time you sold on your own?
If keep more money: Saving on fees is a huge motivator. How are you planning to attract the buyers willing to pay top dollar?
14. "What's your commission?"
You
Are you asking because you want the lowest rate, or because you want to make sure whatever you pay is actually worth it?
If lowest rate: Every dollar counts when you're selling. What's the most important thing to you besides the fee?
If worth it: You should expect a return on that investment. What results would make you feel an agent truly earned their fee?
15. "What do you do to sell homes?"
You
Are you more interested in how we get the home in front of the most buyers, or how we position it so it actually sells once they see it?
If in front of buyers: Exposure is the name of the game. What marketing do you feel was missing last time around?
If positioning to sell: Getting them in the door is half the battle. What feedback did you get on the home's presentation when it was listed before?
16. "Bring me a buyer / do you have a buyer?"
You
Is your goal just to find any buyer, or to put yourself in a position to get the strongest possible offer?
If any buyer: Sometimes speed and simplicity matter most. What's the main reason you're looking for a quick, quiet sale?
If strongest offer: You don't want to leave money on the table. What strategies are you using now to create that kind of demand?
17. "You agents all do the same thing."
You
Do you feel that way because the results have all been about the same, or because no one's really shown you anything different?
If results the same: I'd feel the same in your shoes. What specific results were you expecting that you haven't seen yet?
If nothing different shown: Lots of noise, little substance out there. What would a truly different approach look like to you?
18. "We want to try on our own a couple more weeks."
You
Is that timeline based on actual activity you're seeing, or just giving it more time before making a change?
If actual activity: Momentum is a good sign. What feedback are you getting from the buyers coming through?
If more time: Sometimes you need to see it through. What exactly needs to happen in the next couple weeks for you to feel successful?
19. "We already chose another agent."
You
Are you officially under contract with them, or just planning to move forward?
If under contract: Got it, best of luck to you. (Ethics: don't solicit where a contract is already in place.)
If just planning: Feels good to have someone you're confident in. What stood out from their marketing plan that you think will be key?
20. "We're listing with a friend / family member."
You
Are you working with them because they're truly the best option to get your home sold, or is it more about supporting the relationship?
If best option: What stood out from their marketing plan that you think will be key in getting your home sold?
If the relationship: Because it's that important, I have to ask: how will you handle the conversation if their effort isn't getting the results you need?
Avoidance objections: what to say when a seller wants the call to end
The seller isn't weighing pros and cons, they want out, of the call or of agents in general. The binary question respects their wish to end the call and tells you whether they are done for good or just for now. Listen for: frustration, irritation about how you reached them, or a flat "take me off your list."
21. "I need to talk to my spouse."
You
Is that so you can decide whether selling makes sense, or just making sure your spouse is on the same page with next steps?
If whether selling makes sense: Huge decision, you both need to be comfortable. What are the main concerns you two are weighing right now?
If same page: You want to be a united front. What do you think is the most important thing to your spouse in this process?
22. "I'd never hire someone who calls me out of the blue."
You
Would you say the issue is how you're contacted, or whether the person contacting you can actually help you?
If how contacted: Everyone has a preferred way of doing business. How do you prefer to find the right professional for the job?
If whether they can help: At the end of the day, results are what matter. What qualities are you looking for in an agent who can get the job done?
23. "Take me off your list."
You
Absolutely, I'll do that. Before I go, did you want me to remove you permanently, or just for now?
If permanently: No problem, I'll take care of it. Just out of curiosity, have your plans to move completely changed?
If just for now: I'll give you some breathing room. When would be a better time to check back in on your plans?
24. "Where were you when my home was listed?"
You
Was the challenge getting the home in front of enough buyers, or getting the right buyers to act once they saw it?
If in front of buyers: How was the home being marketed to attract people in the first place?
If getting buyers to act: Getting them in the door is half the battle. What was the most common feedback from people who toured?
25. "How did you get my number?"
You
I use public records and data services that help me connect with homeowners. Is that more of a privacy concern, or just curiosity on how we connected?
If privacy concern: I understand, it can feel intrusive. What's the best way for someone to reach out if they actually have a buyer for your home?
If curiosity: Good to know who's reaching out. Since we're connected, what are your current thoughts on getting the home sold?
A note on the law: you are responsible for following the calling and Do Not Call rules in your area (TCPA, DNC). Check a number before you dial.
How to practice the objection handling playbook this week
- Print the playbook and keep it in front of you during your next prospecting session.
- Before you dial, read the three group descriptions out loud so you know what to listen for in each one.
- Pick the five objections you hear most and say each binary question and both follow-ups out loud until you can ask them without reading.
- On each call, name the group first, then ask the matching question exactly as written.
- After the session, mark which objections came up and which path the seller took, and practice those again tomorrow.
These questions fit inside the old expired listings script and the FSBO scripts, which both use binary questions to answer pushback.