Why calling old expired listings works
A home that expired two to five years ago gets zero calls. The owner still didn't sell, they often still have the same reason to move, and their number has changed since the year they listed. You're usually the only agent calling, and the only one who does real work before asking for anything.
This is the whole conversation in order: the opener, the purpose statement, the where and why questions, the value drop, the callback that earns the appointment, the pushbacks, and the voicemail and text for owners who do not pick up.
The opener for an old expired listing call
You
Hi, is this [Name]? [Name], my name is [Your Name] with [Brokerage], and this is probably a call you haven't gotten in a while. You listed your home on [Street] back in [Year]. Do I have that right?
(Pause. Let them answer.)
The purpose statement
One binary question tells you which way the call goes:
You
Here's why I'm calling. The home didn't sell back then, and most agents stopped calling after a few weeks. I work with homeowners whose plans got put on hold. So can I ask, and it's fine either way: did you ever end up making the move you were planning, or are you still in the home?
If they are still in the home, get the where, then the why
You
Got it. Back then, where were you planning to move?
(Pause. Write it down.)
Oh, [Place]? What's important about that place?
(Pause. This answer is the reason they'll eventually sell. Write down every word.)
The original timeline ended with the old listing, so you're not asking "when" today. You now know where they were headed and why it mattered. You will use both answers in every follow-up.
The value drop: offer what the home would sell for today
You
Here's why I called now instead of never. Prices in [Neighborhood] have moved since [Year], and most owners who listed back then have no idea what that did to their number. Would it be useful if I put together what your home would actually sell for today, or is that not worth your time?
Close call one: commit to the work, get permission
You
Good. Give me a day or two to do it right. What's the best number to reach you when it's ready?
And while I'm at it, would it be alright if I keep in touch now and then with what's happening around [Neighborhood]? Some folks say no, and that's fine.
Then hang up and actually run the CMA. You're the agent who did the work before asking for anything.
Call two: the appointment, earned
You
Hi [Name], [Your Name]. I told you I'd run the numbers on [Street], and I have them in front of me. A couple of things surprised me. When would be a good time for me to come by and review it with you?
Old expired listing pushbacks, answered with binary questions
"We're not interested."
Seller
We're not interested.
You
That's fair. One question before I let you go: is moving off the table for good, or just not right now?
If "not right now": Then I won't bug you. Would you rather I check back when the spring numbers come out, or leave it with you to reach out?
"What do you think the home is worth?"
Seller
What do you think the home is worth?
You
Honestly? I could guess from the outside, but you had an agent guess for you once already and the home didn't sell. Would you rather have a real number built from actual sales around you, or a ballpark right now?
If they want the ballpark: give the honest range, then: That's the guess. Want the real one too?
"We had a bad experience last time."
Seller
We had a bad experience last time.
You
That makes sense. Something went wrong, or it wouldn't have expired. Can I ask: was it more about the price it was listed at, or more about what the agent did after the sign went up?
(Either answer tells you exactly what to solve for. Write it down.)
For more pushback answers, the Objection Handling Playbook has 25 binary questions sorted by objection group.
The old expired listing voicemail and same-day text
Keep the voicemail under 20 seconds, then send the text the same day.
Voicemail
Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] with [Brokerage]. You listed your home on [Street] back in [Year] and it didn't sell. Prices there have moved since then, and I thought you'd want to know what that means for your number. I'll text you as well. No pressure either way.
Text
Hi [Name], [Your Name] here, just left you a voicemail about your home on [Street]. Happy to put together what it would sell for today if that's useful. Want me to?
A note on the law: you are responsible for following the calling and Do Not Call rules in your area (TCPA, DNC). Check a number before you dial.
How to use the old expired listings script this week
- Pull expireds going back three to five years from your MLS or REDX, filtered to homes that never sold.
- Block 45 minutes and call the list before you call today's fresh expireds.
- Every yes on the value drop puts a CMA on tomorrow's calendar and the callback the day after.
- Every follow-up permission goes in your CRM the minute you hang up.
Track one number
Value-drop yeses to review appointments. If owners say yes to the CMA but you're not sitting down to review it with them, the callback is what needs work, so practice call two first.